Below The Ice
  • Home
  • NHL
    • NHL

      Three Things to Watch – The East

      September 17, 2019

      NHL

      Three Things to Watch – The West

      September 10, 2019

      NHL

      NHL Mock Draft 2019

      June 18, 2019

      NHL

      The Friday Three – Stanley Cup Edition

      May 25, 2019

      NHL

      The Friday Three – Final Four

      May 10, 2019

  • Crusaders
    • Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Dec 5 – Feat. Vinny Prospal

      December 5, 2019

      Crusaders

      Cru Wrap – Game 27 vs. Camrose Kodiaks

      November 30, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 28 – Feat. Jake Kendall

      November 28, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 21

      November 21, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 14 – Feat. Max Wutzke

      November 14, 2019

  • AJHL
    • AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Dec 5 – Feat. Vinny Prospal

      December 5, 2019

      AJHL

      Pontiacs Win Three Of Four On Southern Road Trip

      December 4, 2019

      AJHL

      Cru Wrap – Game 27 vs. Camrose Kodiaks

      November 30, 2019

      AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Nov 28 – Feat. Jake Kendall

      November 28, 2019

      AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Nov 21

      November 21, 2019

  • Shows
    • Shows

      Inside The Cru – March 7 – Feat. Arjun Atwal

      March 7, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – Feb 28 – Feat. Liam Horrobin

      February 28, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – Feb 21 – Feat. Kyle Chase

      February 21, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – February 14 – Feat. Josh Healey

      February 14, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – January 24 – Feat. Brayden Hyland

      January 24, 2019

  • The Team
  • Win Column Sports
  • Target Photography
Inside The Cru – Dec 5 – Feat....
Cru Wrap – Game 27 vs. Camrose Kodiaks
Inside The Cru – Nov 28 – Feat....
Inside The Cru – Nov 21
Inside The Cru – Nov 14 – Feat....
Cru Wrap – Game 23 vs the Bonnyville...
Inside The Cru – Nov. 7 – Feat....

Below The Ice

Banner
  • Home
  • NHL
    • NHL

      Three Things to Watch – The East

      September 17, 2019

      NHL

      Three Things to Watch – The West

      September 10, 2019

      NHL

      NHL Mock Draft 2019

      June 18, 2019

      NHL

      The Friday Three – Stanley Cup Edition

      May 25, 2019

      NHL

      The Friday Three – Final Four

      May 10, 2019

  • Crusaders
    • Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Dec 5 – Feat. Vinny Prospal

      December 5, 2019

      Crusaders

      Cru Wrap – Game 27 vs. Camrose Kodiaks

      November 30, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 28 – Feat. Jake Kendall

      November 28, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 21

      November 21, 2019

      Crusaders

      Inside The Cru – Nov 14 – Feat. Max Wutzke

      November 14, 2019

  • AJHL
    • AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Dec 5 – Feat. Vinny Prospal

      December 5, 2019

      AJHL

      Pontiacs Win Three Of Four On Southern Road Trip

      December 4, 2019

      AJHL

      Cru Wrap – Game 27 vs. Camrose Kodiaks

      November 30, 2019

      AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Nov 28 – Feat. Jake Kendall

      November 28, 2019

      AJHL

      Inside The Cru – Nov 21

      November 21, 2019

  • Shows
    • Shows

      Inside The Cru – March 7 – Feat. Arjun Atwal

      March 7, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – Feb 28 – Feat. Liam Horrobin

      February 28, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – Feb 21 – Feat. Kyle Chase

      February 21, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – February 14 – Feat. Josh Healey

      February 14, 2019

      Shows

      Inside The Cru – January 24 – Feat. Brayden Hyland

      January 24, 2019

  • The Team
  • Win Column Sports
  • Target Photography
FeaturedNHL

You’ll Have to Mind The Bollocks…it’s the Jack Adams Award

written by Michael Menzies May 4, 2017

Image courtesy of Canadian Press

While you’re taking a breather from nightly playoff hockey action – the NHL loves to sprinkle in their annual award nominations. It steers the eyeballs away from asking whether Jordan Eberle is truly playing deplorable hockey (unlike a bunch of other Oilers) or if Randy Carlyle has simply conceded McDavid is really good with his famous “white gloves” comment.

The white ones must be the extra skilled gloves I guess.

Recently one award fans and, occasionally, the writers aren’t quite sure what to make of is the Jack Adams award. The Jack Adams award ,awarded to the league’s best coach for the season, has become the NHL’s feel-good story du jour. A chance for the hockey community to celebrate when a bunch of ragtag, lunch-pail players battle hard enough in the corners and exceed everyone’s expectations with their resiliency and sticktoitiveness to only squirm into the playoffs. It makes your heart all gooey.

A week ago now Todd McLellan, the eerily mellowed John Tortorella, and Mike Babcock were nominated for coach-of-the-year. The only winner from the group is Torts from 2003-04, an understandable winner. But the fact that Mike-50-million-dollars-baby-Babcock hasn’t been honoured is surprising. And by surprising, I mean incorrect at this point.

The 2007-08 Detroit Red Wings won the President’s Trophy with 115 points, including 54 regular season wins en route to the Stanley Cup. This would’ve been a great chance to hand Mike Babcock the award. Babcock was also deserving the season before, but they only had 113 points though, which barely tied the President’s Trophy winning Buffalo Sabres mark. Maybe even the season before that one (05-06) where the Red Wings won 58 games and put up 124 points too…or even 2008-09…. although to be fair, Detroit slipped to second in the western conference that season. Unacceptable.

There are plenty of deserving seasons for Babcock. The issue is the NHL broadcasters who vote on the award narrow in on the of-the-year portion of (coach-of-the-year). Which is fine to some extent. But recently, their selections fall into the category described above: the overachieving team.

Or as clever fans point out, next year’s regression team.

Per the NHL, the Jack Adams award is given to the…“NHL coach adjudged to have contributed the most to his team’s success.” The wording invites interpretation, so you can justify many different choices. It’s led to the situation where three consecutive Jack Adams award winners (Paul MacLean, Patrick Roy, and Bob Hartley) have all been coincidentally fired in messy instances merely a couple seasons later. But the messiness didn’t stop with the winners from 2013-2015 as the Florida Panthers proved this year.

Last year’s Florida team of high-flying youngsters and likable veterans like Jagr and Luongo were led by Gerard Gallant, runner-up to Barry Trotz for the coaching title. The hockey nerds with their predictive statistics pegged the Panthers to fall back to earth in the 2016-17 season, during the 2015-16 season. Sure enough, the Panthers regular-season division crown lumped plenty of expectations from the mainstream media their direction. Coupled with a mediocre start (11-9-1) Gallant was soon fired.

The reactionary firing of Gallant seemed strange. He was still the same guy with the same system in place, just lumped with injuries to Barkov and Huberdeau, his best two forwards. When going through a tough start like they were, shouldn’t the dialogue from the team been, “We’re lucky to have Gallant in Florida to help us survive the tough start since he’s one of the best coaches in the league.” I guess not.

To repeat, Gallant was the second best coach from a season ago. Twenty-one games into the season he’s fired.

The Calgary Flames and Bob Hartley followed a similar script. After leaping into the playoffs in 2014-15, Hartley was fired the next season after a regression of twenty points, matching a previous total. Isn’t it more likely Hartley wasn’t overly fantastic for one season, but instead got a few bounces, hot players and they collectively overachieved?

These coaches don’t suddenly get worse after winning the Jack Adams. Did Bob Hartley quit yelling at his team to come back from two-goal deficits in the third period to win in overtime in 2016 compared to before? I don’t think so.

It’s disingenuous for the league to have a circumstance like the 2014-15 season where Bob Hartley wins the Jack Adams by a mile, yet Bruce Boudreau, Michel Therrien, and Ken Hitchcock placed 13th, 14th, and 15th in voting despite leading their teams to division championships. It doesn’t add up.

The coaching award refuses to recognize the best in coaching.

Maybe as fans, we have the wrong point-of-view about the award. Although it’s hard to blame people for thinking the best coaches in the league should be given greater weight for the only coaching trophy, instead of the Roys or MacLeans.

Is hindsight 20-20? Yes, but the point is fans/analysts know whether these coaches are in charge of unsustainable situations. Why is unsustainability valued more in coaching awards than solid structured play and consistency?

For no other reason than Mike Babcock is the coach of the overachieving young-gun filled Toronto Maple Leafs – he should win the award. But outside of the fact he’s one of the best coaches in the world, won a Stanley Cup, and two Olympic golds, he’ll win because he’s finally taking the right path to Jack Adams victory.

Do more than people expect with a “limited” group.

But if the Leafs were coached by Joe Blow or, basically, not Mike Babcock, would his job be on the line if the Leafs miss the playoffs next year by ten points? Looking purely at recent track records, you would have to say it would be.

Joel Quenneville hasn’t won the Jack Adams since joining the Chicago Blackhawks. And frankly, that won’t change anytime soon unless the Blackhawks do something miraculous moving forward. Like, I don’t know, maybe having to change the makeup of your team every year while synthesizing role players with your proven core and still winning the division and playing at a high enough level that people don’t even notice a difference isn’t good enough for a nomination.

Why does Orval Tessier (82-83’s proud champ) have more Jack Adams’ as Blackhawks coach than Joel Quenneville? The closest Quenneville came was in 2012-13 when the ‘Hawks went 36-7-5 during the truncated lockout season. Winning 75% of your games is pretty good. Quenneville – who is second all-time in coaching wins by the way – earned his only title in 2000 with the St. Louis Blues.

From a historical point of view, it’s nice to have an award that represents the coaches. But why are overachievers over-represented, while lessening the impact of the best coaches of all-time? If you’re going to have an award for coaches, why don’t the best coaches consistently get it?

Maybe these aforementioned coaches prove their worth as time goes on, revitalizing their careers. It will be interesting to see how the triumvirate of Paul MacLean-Patrick Roy-Bob Hartley is looked on moving forward. Will Paul MacLean get another job after his stint on the Ducks bench? Will Hartley, who won a cup in 2001, get another call back into the NHL? Will Patrick Roy be given another chance in an environment where his former teammates aren’t the ones hiring him?

Time will tell.

Last season the award correctly itself as Barry Trotz, by all accounts, a mensch, won his first Jack Adams over 1200 games into his NHL career.

Luckily for Babs, the broadcasters won’t miss this chance to make things right this time around. Right?

 

You’ll Have to Mind The Bollocks…it’s the Jack Adams Award was last modified: May 5th, 2017 by Michael Menzies
Jack Adams awardJoel QuennevilleMike Babcock
0 comment
0
Facebook Twitter Google + Pinterest
Michael Menzies

Reporter, Lakeland Connect

previous post
Inside The Cru: Jacob Thomas
next post
Offseason Tasks: Part One

You may also like

NHL 31 for 31: Calgary Flames

September 10, 2018

NHL 31 for 31: San Jose Sharks

September 13, 2018

Which trophy will Matthews’ name grace first?

January 24, 2017

Stanley Cup Playoffs Recap-Day 38-Eastern Conference Final

May 22, 2018

Cru Wrap: February 17th vs Camrose

February 18, 2017

Inside The Cru – February 7 – Feat. Michael Menzies

February 7, 2019

Inside The Cru: Liam Horrobin

May 11, 2017

5 Offseason Moves – Vancouver Canucks

April 28, 2016

Inside The Cru: Ashton Casault

May 18, 2017

GM Rankings (Part One): The Top Half

March 9, 2017

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

About Below The Ice

Here at Below The Ice our goal is to keep you informed. Whether you're looking for breakdowns with the latest advanced stats or opinions on the latest stories from around the hockey world. We're the site for every fan.

Latest Tweets

  • This week on #InsideTheCru @tyleryaremchuk chats with @SPcrusaders d-man Vinny Prospal about the team’s loss to Bon… https://t.co/Wl2ocJy64T

    05-Dec-2019

    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • Jaden York wins it for the @BPontiacs in what was a thriller against the @SPcrusaders tonight at the RJ Lalonde Are… https://t.co/HyH4XGnKMo

    05-Dec-2019

    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • Brayden Krieger snapped home the overtime winner for @BrooksBandits tonight to give them a 2-1 win over the… https://t.co/FDbg1CAvnX

    05-Dec-2019

    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • A pair of AJHLers are heading back to the WHL #AJHL #WHL https://t.co/VwecrNml0g

    04-Dec-2019

    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • We caught up with Michael Menzies - the voice of the Bonnyville Pontiacs - to discuss the Pontiacs four game South… https://t.co/BUOEg5usu7

    04-Dec-2019

    Reply Retweet Favorite

Popular Posts

  • Inside The Cru: Brendan Kallis

    August 31, 2017
  • Cru Wrap: January 13th vs. Calgary Canucks

    January 14, 2017
  • Landing spots for Tavares

    June 28, 2018
  • Industry Talk With Sportsnet’s Kyle Bukauskas

    October 24, 2016
  • Pessimism vs Optimism: An Oilers Conversation

    October 26, 2016
HF Boards

@2016 - Below The Ice. All Right Reserved


Back To Top